Find equal fixtures for less, before the spec is fixed
Upload your fixture schedule or edit the example below. For each line, we check 2 or 3 fixtures from other makers against lumens, color temperature, CRI, mounting, dimming, voltage and DLC listing. Then we price each one from public seller pages and show the savings.
Your file stays in this browser. We do not upload it or keep it.
Your fixture schedule
Sheet 1 of 4Columns: type tag, description, quantity, lumens, CCT, CRI, watts, mounting, dimming, voltage, specified maker and model. The basis unit price is optional. Leave it empty to use our public price for a catalog model. The CSV stays in this browser.
| Tag | Description | Qty | Lumens | CCT (K) | CRI | Watts | Mounting | Dimming | Voltage | Specified maker | Model | Basis $/unit | Best match | Savings | Remove |
|---|
Savings by line
Sheet 2 of 4Savings for each line
Basis line total minus the picked alternate line total. Select a bar to compare that line.
Side by side
Alternates by line
Sheet 3 of 4Each line shows up to 3 fixtures from other makers in our catalog, best match first, then lowest price. Pick one to use it in the totals. Equal means every check passes. Close means one or more checks are near (lumens within 20%, CRI up to 2 points lower, or a lower DLC listing). No match means a check fails.
Questions and answers
NotesShort answers for developers, contractors and architects. Each rule or number from an outside source links to that source.
What does "or equal" mean on a lighting fixture schedule?
The schedule names one fixture as the basis. The contract lets a bidder offer a different product that is equal to the basis. Equal means equal in the characteristics that the specification calls essential. Federal buying rules show how this works. A "brand name or equal" specification must describe the physical, functional or other characteristics that are essential (FAR 36.202(c)). An offer of an equal product must meet them, name the maker and the model, and include product literature (FAR 52.211-6). Private projects set their own rules in the project specifications.
Who approves a substitute, and what goes in the request?
The architect or engineer of record must approve each substitute. The project specifications set the steps and the dates. Public guide specifications show what a request can contain, for example the federal guide section UFGS 01 33 00. In its design-build part, it asks for proof that a substitute is equal "in function, performance, quality, and salient features". The designer of record must approve that proof. The same section warns that unmarked variations can lead to removal of the work at no added cost to the Government. Send the spec sheet, the photometric (IES) file, the warranty and the safety certification with each request.
Which specs should match between the basis and the substitute?
This tool marks an alternate Equal only when every check passes. Lumens are within 10 percent of the line. The line CCT is offered. The CRI is equal or higher. The mounting and dimming match, and the voltage range covers the line. The DLC level is the same or higher when the basis spec sheet states one. The side-by-side table also shows watts, lumens per watt, warranty and the wet or damp rating. Also check the safety certification. OSHA recognizes private testing labs, called NRTLs, that certify products (OSHA NRTL program). After a lab certifies a product, the maker can apply the lab's certification mark. UL LLC, Intertek Testing Services and CSA Group are on the OSHA list.
Why can two fixtures with the same specs look different on site?
Lumens give the total light, not where the light goes. Photometric data shows the light distribution of a fixture, with the intensity in each direction in candela (ANSI on IES LM-63-19). The IES file is a common format for this data. Color can also differ. DOE notes that two products with the same nominal CCT can look very different. Two products with the same CRI can also show colors very differently (DOE color fact sheet). Ask for the IES file and a sample of each substitute. This tool compares only the CCT and CRI numbers, and it does not check the light distribution or glare.
Does the dimming type have to match?
Yes. This tool marks an alternate No match when it does not offer the line dimming type, such as 0-10V, phase (TRIAC or ELV) or DALI. A line with no dimming accepts any alternate. 0-10V and DALI need extra control wires apart from the power wires (DOE dimming report). A matching phase type does not prove that the fixture works with your dimmer. DOE advises a new compatibility check for any substitution of fixtures, lamps or dimmers, in some cases with a test on site. Test the fixtures with the controls over the full dimming range before approval.
What do DLC Standard and DLC Premium mean?
The DesignLights Consortium (DLC) keeps a Qualified Products List of LED fixtures. Premium is the higher level, with higher efficacy (lumens per watt) thresholds and requirements for controllability (DLC). The DLC lists its V6.0 requirements as effective January 5, 2026, and shows December 15, 2026 as the delist date for V5.1. Check the current listing of the exact model before approval. Some rebates need a listed fixture. For example, FPL pays its business lighting rebate only for fixtures on the DLC or ENERGY STAR list (FPL program standards). The list needs a DLC account, so this tool uses only the DLC status on the spec sheet.
How do we cut cost without losing the design intent?
Start from the function, not the first price. Federal guidance defines value engineering as a review that gets the essential functions at the lowest life-cycle cost (OMB Circular A-131). The review must keep the required performance, reliability, quality or safety. For lighting, keep the light levels, the color, the glare control and the controls of the design. Compare watts too. The Florida energy code limits the total connected interior lighting power of a building (Florida Building Code, Energy Conservation, 8th Edition (2023), Section C405.3). A substitute with more watts adds to that total. Get the designer's review before the bid.
How do lead times affect a substitution?
This tool does not check lead times. Ask for a ship date in writing for the basis and for each substitute. Some makers have programs for fast shipping of popular products. For example, Acuity Brands announced its Design Select program in 2023 for products that ship in 15 days or less (Acuity Brands). Check the models again just before you buy. DOE notes that LED and driver models can change during a delayed project, and that this can affect dimming compatibility (DOE dimming report).
Send to a lighting pro
Sheet 4 of 4Get a review before the bid
Copy the brief and send it with your drawings. A lighting pro checks each alternate against the photometry, the code and the design intent, and prepares the substitution request.
A Lighting Certified (LC) designer reviews South Florida projects (Palm Beach, Broward and Miami-Dade). A partner reviews projects in other areas.
Prices are public seller prices that we saw on the date in the brief. A current quote can be higher or lower.
How the match works
NotesWe read the type from the description, or from the model when it is in our catalog. Then we read lumens, CCT, CRI, mounting, dimming and voltage.
We look at every catalog fixture of the same type from another maker. We keep the best one from each maker and show the top 3.
Lumens within 10% at a setting the fixture offers. The same CCT. CRI equal or higher. The same mounting, dimming and voltage. DLC listing when the maker sheet states it.
We use public prices from distributor and retailer pages, with the date we saw them. Lines without a basis price show no savings until you add your quoted price.
| Check | Equal | Close | No match |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lumens | Within 10% of the line | Within 20% | More than 20% off |
| CCT | The line CCT is offered | - | Not offered |
| CRI | Equal or higher | Up to 2 points lower | More than 2 points lower |
| Mounting | Same mounting | - | Other mounting, or the mount is sold separately |
| Dimming | Same dimming, or the line needs none | - | Not offered |
| Voltage | The range covers the line voltage | - | Does not cover it |
| DLC | Same level or higher, when the basis sheet states one | Lower, or not stated | - |
Notes for the owner
Status
- Built 2026-11-07. This build is not deployed. The parent session publishes the site family.
- Name: "Or Equal Lighting" is a working name. "Or equal" is the phrase that specs use for an allowed substitute. We did not use "Spec Saver", because it is close to the Specsavers optician brand (our assumption: a trademark risk). Neither name was checked. Run the ht-name-check skill before launch.
- No backend. The CSV file is read in the browser with FileReader. Nothing is uploaded or stored. The brief is copy-only.
Data and sources (174 unique URLs)
- Catalog: 72 fixtures from 15 makers (Columbia Lighting, Gotham Lighting, Halco Lighting Technologies, Halo, ILP (Industrial Lighting Products), Juno, Keystone Technologies, LEDVANCE, Lithonia Lighting, MaxLite, Metalux, RAB Lighting, Rayon Lighting, TCP, Westgate, Westgate Lighting). Types: 2x4 troffer 8, 2x2 troffer 8, 6 in downlight 6, 4 in downlight 6, strip or wrap 4, vapor tight 6, linear pendant 4, high bay 6, area light 6, wall pack 10, wall sconce 8. Every spec value comes from the maker spec sheet or maker product page in the table below. Values that a sheet does not state are empty.
- Prices: 69 of 72 fixtures have a public price from a distributor or retailer page, seen 2026-11-07, with the URL in the table. The other 3 have no price, and the page says "No public price". We used no estimates. Sellers: 1000Bulbs, Ballastshop, Dale Electric, ELEDLights, Electric Bargain Stores, Electrical Gopher, Elliott Electric Supply, Global Industrial, HomElectrical, LBC Lighting Pro, LEDT8Bulb.com, PROLIGHTING, Rock Lighting & Electric, Superior Lighting.
- DLC: the DLC Qualified Products List (https://www.designlights.org/qpl/ssl/) redirects to a MyDLC login page (https://designlights.org/mydlc/), checked 2026-11-07. So the DLC field holds only the status that a maker sheet prints. Many Lithonia, TCP and Westgate sheets say "not all versions" qualify, so those items show "Not stated".
- Example schedule: each line uses a real catalog model as the basis, with its sheet values and public price. The quantities and room names are our own example numbers. The pendant line (E1) has no public basis price, so it shows how a line without a price looks.
- The raw data is in data/catalog-*.json, data/example.json and data/sources.json. The build is python -I tools/build.py. The engine check is node tools/check.js.
Our assumptions
- A line that needs no dimming accepts a dimmable alternate.
- The "Close" limits are ours: lumens within 20%, CRI up to 2 points lower, or a lower or unstated DLC listing when the basis sheet states one.
- "Same mounting" means that the alternate model lists that mounting without a kit that is bought separately. A mount sold separately is a fail.
- DLC "Listed" (a DLC product ID with no tier printed) counts the same as DLC Standard.
- When the model is not in our catalog, we read the fixture type from words in the description (for example "2x4", "downlight" with "4 in" or "6 in", "wall pack", "high bay").
- We show one alternate for each maker: the best match first, then the lowest price. The default pick is the lowest-priced Equal, then the lowest-priced Close.
- The downlight match sets use 3500K, because the priced spec-grade models were 3500K. Halo and Juno lumens come from their 3000K tables. Westgate sheets do not give lumens by CCT.
To confirm by the LC reviewer
- The match gate itself: lumens within 10%, CCT, CRI, mounting, dimming, voltage and DLC. Should an "or equal" also require the same optic distribution, a glare limit (UGR), housing type, warranty term or emergency option?
- The pairs in the example: Metalux SkyRidge against flat panels, Gotham EVO against canless downlights, Lithonia JCBL against round high bays, Lithonia RSX2 against value area lights (all Type III), Lithonia WST LED against contractor wall packs. Is each pair a fair "or equal"?
- Lithonia WST LED: the sheet brings the 0-10V leads out only with the DMG option, so we list the priced model as not dimmable.
- Some prices came from the seller's own search data for the exact catalog number (Electric Bargain Stores, Rock Lighting, and the Keystone vapor tight at LBC Lighting Pro). The product page URL is in the table.
- The Columbia LXEM4-40ML-DFA-EDU price is the sum of the option prices that a configurator page showed.
- Lithonia 2BLT stock lumens come from an older Lithonia sheet (Rev. 07/21/25). The 2BLT is 82 CRI, so 80 CRI panels fail the CRI check against it.
- MaxLite MLFP flat panel: the sheet does not print the word "grid". We recorded grid mounting.
- The TCP ARC pendant is 4100K. The engine counts it as no match against a 4000K line.
- The area light optic (Type III) is in the descriptions only. The engine does not check the optic.
Engine limits
- No photometric (IES) check. The engine does not compare distribution, spacing, glare, controls compatibility, emergency battery, finish, lead time or build quality.
- The catalog has 72 fixtures. Each type has 4 to 10 models. A line outside our 11 types gets no alternates.
- Prices are single public listings, not contractor or project quotes. Project pricing and volume discounts can differ a lot, and prices change.
- The type read from the description can be wrong. The user can fix it with clear words in the description.
- Savings count only when both prices exist and the pick is not "No match".
Routing plan
- Public text: "A Lighting Certified (LC) designer reviews South Florida projects (Palm Beach, Broward and Miami-Dade). A partner reviews projects in other areas." There is no email address, phone number or person name on the page.
- The brief is plain text with a Copy button. There is no form and no backend. No referral or affiliate tags are set.
Catalog sources
| Maker | Model | Type | Spec source | Public price | DLC on sheet |
|---|
Ask a lighting designer about this project
Send your plan to Holzer Lighting in Boca Raton, Florida. Holzer Lighting designs, specifies and buys lighting for owners, managers, designers and builders.
A designer reads your brief and contacts you. The designer checks the rules, the light levels and the prices for your site. This page gives planning estimates only.
You can also email info@holzerlighting.com or call 561.508.8990.
Other free lighting tools: